Wayne Ishimine
Your Real Estate Specialist

call now

562-619-6356

New California Law Changing How You Sign Up For Home Insurance

October 23,2026 | Posted By Wayne Ishimine in Financial
Share On:

California’s home-insurance market is changing again. On September 28, 2026, Gov. Gavin Newsom signed Senate Bill 876, known as the Disaster Recovery Reform Act. The law takes effect January 1, 2027, and changes both the coverage insurers must offer and the information they must provide to homeowners.

For Californians shopping for homeowners insurance, the biggest practical change is this: insurers will have to offer substantially more protection against the possibility that rebuilding costs exceed the policy’s basic dwelling limit.

What is SB 876?

SB 876 was designed in response to problems exposed by recent California wildfires, particularly the experience of homeowners who discovered after a total loss that their insurance limits were not high enough to rebuild their homes.

The new law addresses several parts of the insurance process, including coverage limits, rebuilding-cost estimates, claims handling and insurer accountability.

For someone buying or renewing a homeowners policy, however, three changes stand out.

1. Insurers must offer at least 50% extended replacement cost coverage

The most important change for people shopping for insurance is the requirement that insurers offer extended replacement cost (ERC) coverage of at least 50%.

Here's why that matters.

Suppose your homeowners policy has a $1 million dwelling limit. If rebuilding your house after a wildfire ultimately costs $1.3 million because construction prices have risen or materials and contractors are scarce, a basic $1 million limit could leave you with a $300,000 shortfall.

With 50% extended replacement cost coverage, the policy can provide additional funds above the basic limit, subject to the policy's terms and applicable requirements.

That extra cushion is particularly important in a catastrophe, when thousands of homeowners may be trying to rebuild simultaneously and construction costs can rise sharply. California's Department of Insurance says the new law is intended to provide more adequate recovery funds through mandatory offers of extended replacement-cost and additional-living-expense coverage.

Starting under the new law, don't simply ask: "How much is my homeowners insurance?"

Also ask:

  • What is the dwelling coverage limit?

  • Does the policy include extended replacement cost?

  • Is the extension 25%, 50% or another amount?

  • What conditions or limitations apply?

  • How is the home's replacement cost calculated?

  • How much coverage is available for additional living expenses?

The headline premium may not tell you which policy provides the most useful protection.

2. You'll get a better idea of what it should cost to rebuild

SB 876 also requires insurers to provide replacement-cost estimates for new policies and renewals. The law specifically addresses the need for homeowners to have information about what it would cost to replace their property. This is important because the home's market value isn't the same thing as its replacement cost.

A house might sell for $1.2 million, for example, while the cost to rebuild the structure could be substantially higher or lower depending on the location, size, construction materials, labor costs and current building codes.

The new requirement should make it easier for homeowners to identify a potentially serious problem: a policy limit that looks reasonable but isn't sufficient to reconstruct the house.

The law also applies this replacement-cost-estimate requirement to the California FAIR Plan, an important point for homeowners who cannot find coverage in the traditional insurance market. 

3. FAIR Plan shoppers will have another important comparison point

California's FAIR Plan has become an increasingly important source of property insurance for homeowners who cannot obtain coverage from traditional insurers.

SB 876 doesn't eliminate the FAIR Plan or guarantee that a homeowner will qualify for private insurance. But the new replacement-cost estimate requirement gives consumers another piece of information when evaluating their coverage.

That's significant because a homeowner should understand not only whether they have insurance, but also whether the amount of insurance would realistically allow them to rebuild.

For people considering a FAIR Plan policy, it's therefore worth looking carefully at the policy's dwelling limit, extended coverage, exclusions and any supplemental policy purchased alongside it.

Will everyone's insurance premium go up?

Not necessarily, and SB 876 itself doesn't establish a specific premium increase.

The law requires insurers to offer additional coverage, but the ultimate price of a policy will depend on the insurer, property, location, wildfire risk, construction characteristics, coverage selections and regulatory approval of rates.

SB 876 isn't only about buying insurance. It also changes the claims process.Insurers will have to maintain disaster recovery plans for handling claims and meeting required timelines. If a new adjuster takes over a claim, the insurer must provide the policyholder with a status report within 15 days. The law also increases penalties for certain violations during declared emergencies and provides for restitution to policyholders when insurers engage in specified unfair claims practices.

That could be particularly significant after a major wildfire, earthquake or other disaster, when thousands of claims can overwhelm insurers and homeowners may be dealing with multiple adjusters and rapidly changing rebuilding costs.

Building-code coverage is also changing

California's building codes are continually updated, and rebuilding an older house after a total loss can therefore cost substantially more than simply reconstructing what stood there before.

SB 876 expands building-code upgrade protection so that, in a total loss, the relevant costs are tied to what would have been required to completely rebuild the structure at its original location. The law also addresses rebuilding elsewhere and the treatment of code-upgrade costs. For homeowners with older properties, this is an especially important part of the new law to understand.

What homeowners should do before January 2027

SB 876 doesn't mean homeowners should wait until 2027 to review their policies. If you own a California home, consider asking your insurer or insurance broker for:

  1. Your current dwelling replacement-cost estimate.

  2. Your current extended replacement-cost percentage.

  3. The maximum amount your policy would pay if rebuilding costs exceed the dwelling limit.

  4. Your additional-living-expense limit and how long it lasts.

  5. Your building-code upgrade coverage.

  6. A written explanation of major exclusions and limitations.

  7. Whether your home qualifies for discounts based on wildfire mitigation measures.

California's insurance market is also beginning to see insurers reopen to new business. In September 2026, the Department of Insurance reported that State Farm and Allstate had filed plans to begin writing new residential policies, although those filings were still subject to regulatory review at the time of the announcement. That means homeowners shouldn't assume the FAIR Plan is their only option without shopping around.

Testimonials

My husband and I have been working with Wayne Ishimine for several years now and we plan to continue our relationship with him and...
- Jocelyn B. - Yelp

DRE# 01192074

Copyright © 2002-2026 Strategic Agent Inc.
Real Estate Websites by Strategic Agent Inc.
Accessibility Help Skip to content Skip to menu Skip to Footer

Text Reader